March 11th, 2008

Your Turn: Open Line Tuesday

I’m busy, so I’m cheating. Today really is your turn — and it’s totally open.

Ask me a question. Make a comment. Make a suggestion. Offer some constructive criticism. As long as you’re polite, I can take it. I’ll do my best to answer questions, but I can’t promise to respond to anything you offer until after my trip to St. Louis this weekend.

Go on now. Have fun!

121 comments to Your Turn: Open Line Tuesday

  • To Preemie Question,

    I would love to offer you my experience with 4 c-sections, 3 preemies, 2 of which were micro preemies. One was at one point 15 oz. the other 1.6 oz. The micro preemies were 8 yrs. apart. One spent 4 months in the hospital, one 3 months, I have been experiencing preemie life now for 10 yrs. The NICU is just the beginning. I have a non profit group for preemies and their families. There really is a great deal to share but I would need to correspond more personally. You can also visit http://www.joeysbrigade.blogspot.com or http://www.littleelly.blogspot.com to see my journey.

    She is not alone and I would be happy to help you and her in any way that I can. Please e-mail me at joeysbrigade@hotmail.com

    God Bless you and please tell her that my 15 oz. baby is now almost 9 yrs old.!!

    Gina

  • findinghumility

    This is for Elizabeth, due with her third baby soon:

    I have many friends with the same feeling you have towards labor and birth. I have had two uncomplicated labor and deliveries both with no medication. My friends think I’m nuts because I actually get excited about the birth part. I’ve always been a sucker for a challenge so I tend to get myself psyched up to fight through it. I think something that helps me when I do get nervous about labor is reminding myself that God created our bodies the way they are to give birth. Down to the very hormone changes that occur and natural epidural effects that can happen during labor or more so delivery. The way a womans contractions will often spread out at times she needs a rest etc. I know complications can arise, but I have a great deal of faith in God’s creation of me as a woman and mother. I trust in that. And when all else fails I remind myself to offer up my pain in prayer for those in purgatory…pain with a purpose is much easier to endure. When I look at labor as an impending spiritual journey it calms my nerves and helps remind me of the beautiful creation that will follow.

  • Melissa G.

    Danielle, No questions. I just wanted to chime in and say “Thank you.” Thank you for reminding me that motherhood is a vocation and not just a thankless job. Thank you for inspiring me and challenging me to live my life for Christ and not others. Thank you for reminding me to cherish each moment with my husband and my children. Thank you for your wisdom, wit, humility, vulnerability, humor, and prayers. God Bless You!

  • Karen in Florida

    I am a SAHM of 5 children and pregnant with #6. My question is about Catholic Schooling. Our Bishop has recently mandated that the Catholic schools in our diocese must go to a “cost-based/cost-needs” system– meaning that the tuition cost will go up so that they are equal to the true cost of educating a child– and no discounts for having multiple children!! The true cost at our children’s school is $7431 per child. My husband is the sole provider for our family, and though he makes a good salary, we will have 4 children of school age next year and the cost for tuition is going to be astronomical! (and we know we have at least 2 more kids coming down the pipeline still!) I am wondering what other families do when faced with this situation. I feel like our Bishop is acting crazy and his policies are punishing those of us who are trying to be open to life. It seems as though being open to life and being able to afford catholic school are incompatible concepts! I feel so frustrated. We really want to support our Catholic school and I really don’t want to homeschool, but it seems like that is our only other choice. (The public schools here are pretty scary, and I don’t feel comfortable trusting our children’s souls there.) Our Bishop has said that this is the model that most of the country is adopting. Are other people really going through this throughout the country? I realize many of your readers are homeschoolers– but am wondering what is going on in other dioceses?? Thanks so much, Danielle. I love your blog and am a faithful daily reader!! :-)

  • Anonymous

    I am new to reading this blog. As a homeschooling mother of 4 ages 5, 4yr twins, and a 19month old, these comments are very encouraging. It is encouraging to know that I am not the only one who is struggling to keep my patience with the kids while trying to march forward on the pilgrimage God has called me too. Reading about other’s struggles helps me to realize that we are all broken, trying to find a way to live a holy life and that I am not alone in dealing with the frustrations of temper tantrums, spilled milk, etc wondering if I can handle another day. I am wondering if there is any way for you to make open replies about topics like these more available. I find it hard to meet other Catholic ladies that share the same goals and sentiments. Hence, reading these blogs is quite encouraging.
    A more specific question for you….what are some things that have been helpful to you that help you remain strong in combatting the world’s philosophy about money and the need for children to have so many

  • Anonymous

    Woops-hit a button! Again the question, what has been helpful to you to help you remain strong in combatting the world’s philosophy about money and the need for children to have so many “experiences?” In a large family, it seems to be difficult to find the money and time, etc to do a lot of extracurriculars, visit museums, go on vacations, etc?
    Thanks for the wonderful blog and the many funny posts.

  • Therese

    One thing to think of when you feel overwhelmed by the constsnt demands of young children…what ou are doing is so worth it.
    We have four children, and our oldest, who is now 22, has been dating a young woman for a couple of years. Although she was Batized Catholic, her family has never practiced their Faith. Recently, he told me that she would like for them to live together before they get married. My son asked me, “What do you think?” I tried very hard to contain myself from blurting out what came to mind, and calmly asked him…”I think you are a grown man who knows what is right. What’s imporatant is what do YOU think?” And he said, “I think it’s wrong. I think we need to wait to get married before we have that kind of a relationship. That is how God wants it to be. It worked for you and Dad, and that is what I want. And if she does not feel that way, then maybe she is not the one I should marry.” He went on to talk about all his memories of growing up…and all of it centered around the time we spent with him and the faith we raised him in. And nothing was of grand proportions…it was little things like back yard campouts and Home Masses and family board game night. Clearly, they meant something to him.
    So when the laundry and dishes pile up, when you have no time to yourself, when the children need you all night long…one day you will see your child become the man or woman you raised him or her to be…and it will so be worth it.

  • Mary

    Anonymous @11:57– I am so sorry for your pain. That sounds hollow, but know that you will be in my prayers. Please, for your sake, remove all the alcohol from your house. If the drinking is a problem — get the stuff out. There is no valid reason anyone can give as why any household has to have even one bottle. Of course, that doesn’t deal with the underlying issues but it is a great first step. You know that, at best, it only partially numbs the pain while adding an additional problem into the mix. Maybe your strength in giving up drinking might give your husband impetous to put aside the sites he is visiting. That sort of thing can be soul crushing too, Anonymous. A friend of mine has issues in that area and for the his sake has come to realize he must not use a computer except for SOLELY work related usage. When he speaks in general terms about that periods of his life the pain he still feels is nearly palpable. As mentioned by others, I’d also recommend Retrouvaille – http://www.retrouvaille.org/.
    For the mom worried about the whole socialization issue for her kids if she home schools them… The nicest kids we know are the homeschoolers. Because of physical disabilities I am not capable of homeschooling my son, yet, even though he is an only child, I would if I could. We feel blessed to be involved with the homeschooled kids in Emmitsburg, MD. Truly blessed. Their parents are actively involved in their upbringing and conciously promote an vibrant Catholic culture. If someone has more than one child or if they have only one and there are other homeschooling families in area, I would encourage them to try it. The results I have seen make me thank God for those willing and capable of doing it. They are making some big sacrifices that can only improve our world.
    T with Honey — Your post made me remember a school Mass that I attended when I had to have been 8, 9 at the most. It was probably 1971 or so. Someone dressed in a black leotard performed “Morning Has Broken.” This was cutting edge stuff at the time. We were even told it was a significant move in the Church. Ohhhh, ahhhh… we were prepped to appreciate this extra dimension of worship. Just the same, even to my young mind, it didn’t seem appropriate. Liked the song – first time I had heard it – but didn’t think that was the place for such expression. I hope you speak to your pastor and listen to that which the Holy Spirit places in your heart.
    Danielle — Hope you have a great time in St. Louis!
    Peace. ~~~mary
    P.S. Julie — May I suggest turning off the computer when the 3 year old is around? That or be sure you teach him to go to Amazon through Danielle’s portal so she gets credit. lol

  • Paige

    I am house sharing right now with another woman who has 3 kids (my husband is deployed and she was kind enough to open her house to me so I wouldn’t be alone after I have my 5th child in april). All totaled we have 7 kids under 7 between the two of us.

    The thing we are finding the most difficult is MEALS. They are SO chaotic. Especially breakfast when everyone seems to be absolutely starving. They crowd in the kitchen trying to get peeks of what is being cooked…some of the little hands like to swipe! It seems that we spend the first hour of every morning being nagged to death by small “starving” children. By the end of breakfast we are both wondering why we even got out of bed. lol.

    Can you walk us through your morning routine…and what you make your kids for breakfast. We need ideas for what is cheap but has a quick prep time.

  • Karen in Florida:
    Feel your pain. There are several schools going to the “actual cost tuition” structure. I believe it is an incredible penalty to those of us trying desperately to simply live on one income, let alone educate the children we have been given and may yet still have.

    The bishops are in an understandable financial bind; the cost of education is sky-high. When nuns and brothers taught in the schools there might have been some chance to break even, but now that is the exception. Where will the money come from? Obviously we want Catholic education to continue. Unfortunately, this method of making everyone pay the real costs will result in only the very richest Catholics — and anyone else willing to pony up the cash — being able to afford Catholic education in school.

    What burns me is that we are still hearing about sacrificing, and how our parents and grandparents were poor too, and how they still sent their kids to school. My answer to that is, the tuition to cost of living ratio was a fraction of what it is for an average one-income family today. Today, to have to pay more than your mortgage is out of the question. And many people who are living on one income have trouble doing that. L ike us…

    My belief is that soon there will be so many people who cannot afford even the mediocre Catholic schools that either the system will change drastically, or homeschooling will become even more common than it is today.

  • Anonymous

    A thought about the praise songs during Mass. Our church uses them, at ALL the Masses if they are included as part of the music for the weekend – no special contemporary or kids Mass. We don’t do the hand motions with them, however, some people clap or put their hands in the air if they wish. My thought is the recessional hymn is after Mass has ended, since Mass is ended when the priest gives the blessing and then says, “Go in peace to love and serve the Lord.” So if you wanted to do a praise and worship song with hand motions maybe it would be more comfortable to do it there. We are praising God, but Mass is officially over, so it wouldn’t necessarily be that the children were performing during Mass. I don’t know, just a thought.

  • karen g.

    Danielle, have you ever considered sponsoring a “sister site” where devoted readers can do what we’re doing here, but in an organized fashion? (Oh shoot, they have a name… is it listserve?) That might be too big a beast to take on, but it sure would be cool! Maybe there already is a site out there that someone could recommend.

    Thanks for this website. From what I understand you started it just to practice your writing … but it seems to have turned into something much more than just that!

  • Breakfast idea

    Paige, you could try cooking oatmeal in the crockpot overnight. Put one cup of steel cut oats (find them in the bulk bin at your grocery store or health food store) and four cups of water. Cook on low from 10pm to 7am. Serve with a little cream, or maple syrup, raisins, honey, dried cranberries, or whatever way the children will eat it. I like mine with agave nectar.

    Some mornings I wake before my three under five and make a fast pancake (you can make the dry mix the night before) or eggs and toast.

    And other mornings I have been known to let PBS distract them until breakfast is served!

  • me

    Danielle:

    You can always FREEZE bananas that are past their eating date to make banana bread later. I often throw them in whole, if I have room, or you can mush them into a ziploc or freezer container. That way, they are pre-mashed! Works like a charm!

  • I love you guys. Keep ‘em coming.

  • StephC

    Um, you mean that some of you actually make banana bread with bananas that are NOT black & frostbitten like the ones pictured???

    Shoot, that’s the only kind I’ve ever used! (I once counted up ziploc bags & had 20 (yes, twenty) frozen black bananas waiting patiently for me to get inspired.)

    Re: Ovarian cysts…I have read that flaxseed oil (1-3g/day) helps, and that ibuprofen/NSAIDS are to be avoided.

  • Cornhusker

    To Canadianmom (and anyone else who wonders the same thing): I was homeschooled from 1st through 8th grades, went one semester to a “Catholic” (my mom won’t call them that since it really isn’t accurate here. She calls them “tuition-charging schools”) high school, then was homeschooled until 2nd semester senior year. At that time, we were on the early end of homeschooling and thought it might be good to have a diploma. Nowadays, colleges have had enough homeschooled kids that they don’t really care about the diploma, as long as ACT/SAT scores are good. I am one of four and we all did something a bit different for high school. My brother went full time to a tuition-charging school. My sister did one year of that, then part-time to a public high school. My youngest brother did all four years part-time in public school. None of us had any problem getting into college and we all did well. I should note that none of us credit our good higher education careers to our institutional schooling – quite the opposite! Anyway, the point is, look at each individual child when the time comes rather than relying on a “one size fits all” solution for high school. And don’t worry about how they will do in college. During high school I did take some classes at a local university through their “early entry program,” pretty much like AP courses except the real thing. That type of thing might help you gauge how they are doing academically as well as help you feel confident that they are learning whatever you don’t feel competent to teach.

  • Liz

    canadianmom, both my kids were homeschooled all the way until college. They did each take some college courses while still living at home before going to college full time. What they found was that they were far better prepared than the students that had been to public school (even better than the ones who’d taken AP courses). As a matter of fact, one of my daughter’s friends told her that homeschooling shouldn’t be allowed because homeschoolers had an unfair advantage when they got to college. We weren’t terribly organized, we didn’t finish textbooks, and the kids did no more than 3 hours a day of schoolwork all the way through high school. Yet they both graduated from university which they attended on scholarship (merit based). One graduated with a B- average, the other graduated magna cum laude.

    The real key as I saw it was making learning an attractive thing and then giving them at least some freedom to pursue areas of learning that interested them without a whole lot of assessment in those areas. There will be areas where you have to have accountability because of the state, but they need to have some areas where they can chart their own course, so to speak. My daughter did this in both domestic arts and in animal training and the sciences, my son was far more interested in history, geography ornithology, and theology. They continue to pursue their own independent interests as adults and are interested now in the things they didn’t learn in college. I must say that a lot of those independent interests actually were of more assistance to them in college than the formal curriculum we followed.

  • AJM

    Regina –

    I completely understand what you are saying. I have been struggling with post-partum depression for over a year now. It sometimes seems like everyone calls me because I’m a good listener, but who ever takes the time to listen to me?? Not that I was completely forth-coming wth the problems I was having… But I desperately wanted someoneto listen to me and hear with I was struggling with.

    We recently move cross-country and I am making it a point not just to meet people, but to invest time with people I truly enjoy being with and to make friends that reciprocate in the listening department.

    My husband is so wonderful and really my best friend, but women still need women friends to talk to. It taking a while, but I have been persstent in getting involved in activities that I enjoy and through those I have met some wonderful, true friends.

    I have foud great strengh in Danielle’s Lenten posts – she’s obviously a loving and devoted mother and yet she still struggles with making time to do the little things with her kids – like sitting to read books and not rushing through bedtime, etc. We all have our strengths and weaknesses. And that’s ok.

  • Danielle you rock. You rock!

  • Seriously, though, are there any small-family people out there? Some of us have fantasized about being the “homseshooling (or active PTA) mom of five (or six or whatever)”, and yet reality is something different. How does anyone else show that they are as open to life as a big-family-mama? How does anyone else not get up into someone else’s face when they push and push and push your buttons? Do you know how many parents of only-two-thank-you get on my case about having only one child? On a daily basis sometimes? How does anyone else keep from throttling the next person who points out that their husband/father/mother/grandchild is an only child and so miserable? How do you answer them with grace?

  • For Findinghumility about the foster kid thing: my family of origin took in a lot of foster kids and people in trouble.

    As an adult, I talked to my mom about it and she said that if she had to do it over she would not have taken in kids that were older than her biological kids and basically she wouldn’t have done it before we were teenagers.

    This is NOT saying that you are doing the wrong thing, just that caring for foster kids, of itself, takes a tremendous amount of emotional (and physical) energy. Taking care of 4 kids under 4 will be that way anyway (My oldest was 4 when my 4th was born), but the foster issue does multiply the problem. Again, this is not to say that this is not what God is calling you to do, but it does require careful discernment flowing from your sacramental union.

    And, yes, it would be normal to feel extremely overwhelmed and have trouble emotionally bonding! :)

    I will be praying for you today!

  • LadyHatton

    Thank you Ambrose, I was just thinking the same thing. Our older son has autism and although we tried for years to have another child we were not so blessed until our older boy was 8.5. The number of people who asked me if we “decided not to have any more after we got D’s diagnosis” would amaze you. I usually responded, “I’d have ten, ok, six, if they were all like D” and that shut them up :) Also I would be taken to task when I expressed my pro-life beliefs, people pointing out that I had “only one child” and I did not “need to work”. AAGGh. Also I am surrounded by cultural Catholics who talk openly about ‘being Done’ and being “all tied up” and think cohabitation once you are engaged is no big deal. It is very disheartening. Just wanted to vent, thanks, Oh and I hope I am not banned from this list because our children attend public school. In NYC yet. Oy. I appreciate how Danielle provides a forum where we can all express our thoughts IN CHARITY. Thanks everyone and God Bless You.

  • Midwest Mom

    Regarding the cost of Catholic Schools – We are in the same situation. The only parish school we could get into is $5500/year with no multiple child discount etc. We’d have 5 in. It bums me out – my husband makes great money, but I don’t see $27,500 coming our of our budget anytime soon. I homeschooled for two years and loved many things about it, but decided after much prayer it isn’t for us right now. So I did the unthinkable! I enrolled our oldest in the public school at the end of our block. Granted, we are in one of the highest rated school districts in the country . . . so it’s a solid academic program, but it’s not Catholic…. and guess what!? we dig it. It is wholesome and the school goes out of its way to communicate the “whats/whens” of anything that could potentially be controversial (i.e teaching the human reproductive system). This school only goes to 5th grade, and then we plan on 70% homeschooling junior high and having her attend the other 30% pt at the local junior high. I still homeschool religious ed, gramamr and Latin. Works for us!

  • My heart goes out to so many of you. I have no words that have not already been said. I will offer my Holy Hour tomorrow night for you. I will pray for you all.

    Danielle, including you, since you have to answer all these!!! Extra prayers for you! Thank you for all you do!

  • Jen

    I also live in the midwest, but haven’t heard of this increase in Catholic tuition…thank goodness.
    Hmmm…does your parish have tuition assistance? All of ours around here offer that as an incentive to help out those who can’t afford it, you also have tax benefits when you file your tax returns. Also, there is a tax incentive based “scholarship” fund that people can sign up for (kind of like financial aid for college) that can help to pay a portion of their tuition.
    I hope some of these options are available and just not known to all of you. I’m sorry not to have the specifics, but if you need more info, I’ll check with my husband. He handles the more complicated issues dealing with our finances.

    Good luck!

  • Amy

    RE: Preemies

    I cannot imagine how much pain your friend is in! I just had my third child. I was counting on a normal, natural delivery. She was by c-section and I felt devastated. Other than the c-section, everything went perfectly well and she was perfectly healthy. The reason for my grief was that I equate a c-section with a limitations on the number of future pregnancies. I wanted lots of kids, but now this means lots of c-sections (Vbacs are not allowed any hospital within two hours of us). I was crushed. Could this mean only three or four for me?

    Now, top this with a preemie, time in the NICU, and it only being her first – your friend is truly grieving! Some of this grief will subside once the hormones balance back out, but she will still have some hurt. I would suggest sharing the stories of others who have been through this. My sister-in-law nearly lost her baby and herself with her first. She went on to have six more kids (two miscarriages), and with only half a kidney! Finding the stories may be tough, but hearing them helped me.
    Shower her baby with attention and praise. This may indirectly remind her how precious each is, and that she should concentrate on and be thankful for this one now (just don’t say this to her! She is having a hard enough time trying to keep this in mind). Also, help her in ways you would help any new mom. Bring over meals, offer to clean, off to help mailing out birth announcements, etc. Once the baby is home, offer to come over and hold her while mom rests, or sits and chats with you. The overwhelming task of a new baby adds to her difficult situation, and you can help lighten this.

    RE: Potty training – STICKERS!!!! I got my eldest a blank book, her “sticker book” which we used the same way as a the previously mentioned chart, but without a formal chart. She put the stickers wherever and however she wanted. She could sit on the potty with her book until she went. It worked great!

  • Amy

    Liturgical abuse resources:

    EWTN : Faith Q&A (online)

    Adoremus.org

    St-joseph-foundation.org

  • music

    First…Danielle…this must truly be Lent because you will have SO many questions to answer.

    Secondly, regarding Praise and Worship Music…I definitely see your point…here is another.

    Youth are attracted to contemporary Praise and Worship. I strongly encourage the youth of our parish to listen to Christian music rather than the other “trashy” alternatives that are so readily available. MANY times youth have been listening to Christian music and will say to me, “will this work for OUR church?” Confused, I finally asked them to be specific on what they ment by “our” church. Here is a summary of two of their comments, they felt it was a sin/wrong to sing any other songs other than CATHOLIC songs inside the church.

    We had a very good discussion about which songs were appropriate for each part of the mass and why. I also showed them songs that were sang ANYWHERE. I also showed them more traditional songs and explained why they were Catholic. I explained that not all songs need to be “fast/hip”. By the time I was done, there were MANY kids listening, not just two.

    I guess what I want to say is educating our youth is so important. I know how hard it is to volunteer. I agree with you about the “performance”, but I am also hearing the needs of our youth. Is there a balance?

  • Amy S.

    Danielle,

    We obviously have a lot of questions, as well as a lot of advice. Perhaps once a week you could choose someone’s question and leave it open for responses. I know you do this every once in awhile, but there are surely enough questions out there to do it on a regular basis. I would think this would lighten your load, and I’m sure those of us on the receiving end would appreciate it!

  • Donna L.

    Danielle,

    Thank you for opening this up for ALL the different questions that have been offered so far…..there is nothing too small to be addressed and beloved recipe requests DO NOT detract from the tougher situations that some of the families in this corner of the blogosphere are having to endure.

    I am glad that this is a safe forum to ask hard, heart-breaking questions, as well as banana bread and brownie recipes and everything in between. That is what having *friends* is all about: encouraging and commiserating about life: the big stuff and the minutia. It is all important.

    Thank you once again,

    Sincerely,
    Donna

  • momofsome

    To the anonymous with the difficult marriage, some thoughts:

    One, take care of yourself to help you deal with this. Your first priority is prayer, and we all know how hard that can be when you have everything else on top of you. Try to take a walk outside everyday. Mind and body are connected and one will help the other. While you are walking, complain to God. That’s right, complain to God. Tell Him about you and your marriage and what you want. God knows the type of life that He wants for you and your husband. Prayer will get you there. Remember that you have great (and specific) graces available to you from the Sacrament of Matrimony that you share.

    Two, some great suggestions have been Retrovaille (or however you spell it) and a holy priest. Excellent suggestions. Keep in mind, though, if you need it, there is website called catholictherapist.com. They will help you find a faithful, Catholic therapist in your area to help you (and your husband, when he is ready) when or if the time comes.

    Lastly, ladies who are home with littles and going out of your minds (been there, well, am there), please pray for the ladies here who have so graciously shared their problems. When I feel like I’m trapped and can’t go out to evangelize the world, I remember that St. Therese of Lisieux prayed for missionaries from her little sickbed. In our little, hidden lives we can pray for those who are hurting so badly with our little sacrifices (dirty diapers, husbands who “just don’t appreciate us”) and all of the little crosses we have in our daily lives.

    Thanks, Danielle, for this forum. I know many have been helped by having the ability to share these parts of their lives anonymously.

  • Amy S.

    In honor of the upcoming feast of the Annunciation, how about another fund raiser for St. Gianna’s?

  • Ambrose and Lady Hatton, I hear you! I have three lovely daughters and would love to have more if/when I can take care of a medical issue, but as I’m approaching 40 I realize that “more” might be “one or so more if we’re really blessed and really lucky” etc. Which is fine, but far short of the large family I’d planned on having.

    To me, that was part of the challenge: accepting the fact that I’d always assumed that God would give any woman who was open to life and actively desiring children all the children she could possibly have, whole vans full, even. Since things haven’t worked out that way for me, I’ve become much more aware of two things–one, that many women desire children greatly but are infertile, or have one, or two, or some number far fewer than they’d always “planned” on having; and two, that my own tendency in my younger years to judge every small family and assume that they had to be using contraception was a very sinful attitude on my part, a sin of rash judgment directed against my neighbors.

    Women who are blessed with large families are living a very visible counter cultural witness to the world and its false values, and this special grace is, I think, granted them in light of the very real sacrifices and hardships that mothering a large family entails. Those of us who are never going to fill a full-sized van with our blessings can still witness to the world, though; it just takes more direct action on our part, a willingness to speak up if someone assumes we’re “planning” our families, an openness to welcoming larger families into our homes and lives, and the quick and generous response we can make in charity to the needs of the larger families around us. If that charity takes the form of financial contribution, that’s fine, but if we can’t give material goods we can often offer our time in some way; we can certainly offer our prayers and whatever cheerful solidarity we can give to the moms of many.

  • Susan

    To Lady Hatton and Midwest Mom,

    Our five children attend our neighborhood public school and we love it, much more so than we thought that we would when we nervously enrolled them years ago. All the hype, scary stories and rumors were just that, scare tactics by well meaning but ignorant folks. Do what’s right for your family because nobody knows your situation but you. There are times when I feel like a persona nongrata in some Catholic circles, but then I remind myself that JP2 attended public school. And of course, my children are happy.

  • Elizabeth

    To the mother who was disappointed after having a c-section and questioning the number of children she will be able to have:

    Though the nearest hospital that will let you attempt a VBAC is two hours away I would seriously consider trying to deliver at one of those with your next pregnancy, or trying for a home birth. No hospital should have the motto “Once a c-section, always a c-section.” Our local hospital has that motto and that is one reason I drive over an hour away to a different hospital. I have never had a c-section but I did not want to give birth in an enviroment that was so medical and non-bending. Unless there is something different about your body that requires a c-section there is no reason that you can not attempt and succed with a VBAC and there is NO reason to have a c-section unless in an emergency or when there are problems with a mother’s body or baby (breech, etc.). So rather than worry now about your future births and number of children enjoy that precious baby that you have now and then think of your options once you get pregnant next time…driving so far to have a VBAC is not a terrible thing when the opposite would just be a c-section.

  • Plug for “The Proper Care and Feeding of Husbands” by Dr. Laura Schlessinger. No it is not from a Catholic perspective. We need to apply Catholic teaching. But women must stop trying to make men into our girlfriends. Men think and act differently. They have needs that we promised to try to fulfill all the years of ourlives. Everytime I have ignored my moods, will etc and just tried to do 1 nice thing for my husband, the entire home was better for the entire day— Even if no one but God knew!

    CSects: I’ve had 5. First one allowed for VBacs for the next 2 children. But the next 1 was a true emergency so that I was told to be extremely cautious. Yes we had 3 more and I wouldn’t trade for anything but it was very frightening for the physicians. They had seen ruptured scars. There is no warning sign. There is no way to predict.
    The good news is you might get to pick your childs Birthday. The ONLY bad news is 8 weeks recovery instead of 6. And a scar no one besides your husband will see.
    It does not have to be a defeat. My husband is very proud of how well he can run our family while I recover.
    Without CSections my Sarah might have suffered Cerebral palsy or died at birth. Without Csects my Memere grieved for 60 years, a stillborn that could have been saved.
    God will be there for you.

  • Nicole

    Dear Danielle,

    What is your favourite colour?
    What is your favourite number?
    Who is your favourite male & female Saint?
    What is your favourite month of the year?
    What is your favourite book?
    What is your favourite movie?
    What is your favourite song at the moment?
    What is the best compliment you’ve ever received?

  • busy mom

    I read earlier about how someone recommended a listserv or more open questions. Have to say-I’d love it. I love reading what other people have to say, especially those on this blog.

  • Apologies to Kateri, but I must say… hermit crabs are gross.

    ;-)

  • Monica

    What do you do for Easter baskets?

    Also, how do you handle birthday/Christmas presents? We have 2 girls and one baby in utero and I already feel like we’re drowning in presents each holiday and birthday. We give away on a regular basis. How do others handle this?

    Danielle, thank you for the encouragement and laughs and your beautifully Catholic blog. I love it.

  • Mary

    Ambrose –
    Even though at 44 I have only one child, I have no need to “show” that I am open to life and that works for me. I don’t know if I’m more or less open to life than anyone else and don’t feel called to look into the matter. Perhaps, this comes from the fact that I try to openly discuss life issues as situations are made available. If you are aware of the issues involved in that big issue – LifeNews.com’s newsletters are great for the national/international info – then you’ll find yourself capable of interjecting a life viewpoint into many a conversation. Also, if you are busy participating in parish and diocesan pro-life initiatives, coupled with visiting a nursing homes to enhance the lives of the elderly and disabled – plus offering prayers for the cause – I doubt anyone will be able to rankle you about your degree of dedication to the promotion of God’s abundance. God is love. Being pro-life is a matter of being open to sharing that love. If you show a child a positive approach to a situation, then you are sharing that love. If you wipe the face of a drooling patient, you are sharing that love. If you smile at a frustrated cashier even though they may be further impeding your own frustrating day, you are sharing that love. If you donate used clothing to the poor, you are sharing that love. If you help load an elderly person’s groceries, you are sharing that love. If you take communion to the homebound, you are sharing that love. In that love that is shared grows, everyday affords each of us opportunities to give birth to the precious gift of love – God’s gift of love.
    I personally think that we women with small families can be a blessing to our sisters with big family, and visa versa. I’ve never known a friend to say she can’t use a bit of a hand or even a break. This then gives me a chance to throw my son into the mix of the chaotic fun of a full house. He loves it — every bit of it — from tying shoes to impromptu kick ball games.
    Ambrose, if someone is so thoughtless as to say something negative about your family situation and you really want to say something to them, simply say, “I know you don’t mean to be offensive, therefore, I have to tell you that what you just said could be very hurtful to someone. I thought you’d want to know.” Then pray for them. It has to be tough for them to have to be so terribly petty.

  • To Ambrose, Red Cardigan and LadyHatton,
    We too are a smaller family, and for a variety of reasons will probably stay that way. While I sometimes wish for more children, I have come to discern that God has gifted us in different ways, and it’s our job to figure out the best ways to use His gifts. I love what Red Cardigan said in regards to this, and I totally agree.
    As for school, we too are a public school family. My husband is in public school administration now, and formerly was a teacher and principal. We’ve seen it from all angles, good and bad. For us, it’s the right place for our kids, and they are thriving. I do religious ed. at home, and they take classes at our wonderful parish.

  • Anonymous

    To Karen in Florida

    I am a teacher in the Catholic School system in the Archdiocese of New York. Yes, your bishop is right, those changing are taking place. Catholic Schools are struggling to survive. Teachers in Catholic schools do not make a great salary. We sacrifice in salary for what we believe in. What is driving up costs so much is health insurance, and other benifits. Many of us do not take health insurance because our husbands have it, and that saves over $20, 000 a year per teacher. Yes, that is how much health insurance costs, it’s ridiculous. There are some teachers who must take their health insurance benefit because they are single or have no other health insurance. These teachers deserve these benefits just like any other person in the workforce. It is a shame that the cost of Catholic Education is so out of reach for so many people today.

  • anony

    hi-here is an intimate and embarassing question. maybe some can relate or give their input. i would really like that. thanks.
    well, i am wondering if it is a common thing that moms of young kids (many young ones) have a hard time coming to “completion”? is this an alright thing to ask? i have posted on ewtn faith questions with no results. i am at a lost. i am learning to accept this. i have “never” you know and been married close to 10 years now with baby 6 on the way. i adore myhusband and i know he adores me too. it saddens him immensely. we have tried to have things quiet, clean, tried some wine, relaxed, gone away for a weekend. the list can go on. well, nothing happened. it is very easy for him to and i am accepting that maybe this is a cross. or is it? is this a normal thing? do others go through all this too? is there a slim possiblity? or is it just no. i asked my obgyn a few years ago and he confirmed there is nothing physically wrong.
    i am relieved to be able to ask out there and get some real answers. oh, my husband and i are very adherent to our Catholic Faith and would do nothing not in line with our Church and her beautiful teachings. i have read theology of the body too.
    i hope someone out there can relate or give me advice. thanks. sorry if it is a bit personal.

  • Anonymous

    Gee, You must think I am an awful teacher, my grammar wasn’t very good in that last post. I meant to say “changes” instead of changing. Had a hard day today. Too many sad things this week. First my cousin’s daughter who passed away at 26, then my best friend’s Mom early this morning. Then, car trouble this afternoon. Sorry to whine, but I think that I deserve it today.

  • Dear Anony,
    I wish I had asked a good group rather than the wrong people years ago. I will say wine/caffeine/sugar doesn’t help. It does not have to be at the same time as his and you’ll love getting older because it usually helps. At a certain age your body finally gets it act together.

  • Teresa G.

    Dear Anony,

    I would like to give some thoughts on your question, but am a bit hesitant to do it here for “all the world” to see. I think I can discreetly share some things that might help. But I’d rather do it privately through email. If you’d like, you can email me at: ggiorgio@roadrunner.com. I think Danielle will vouch for me…..she knows me and knows I”m not a stalker or a wacko!!
    Teresa

  • anony2

    I have the same problem…. would love help…. although I think my problem might be more mental/emotional.

  • Jeanne Kateri

    This is for Kateri:

    My mommy says we can have chickens if my daddy says its okay. How much work/time is involved once your hens are fully grown and laying eggs every day? How many do you have? Is it enough for you not to have to buy eggs at the store?

    I like your name!!!!