I’m a little late getting to this, as last week was TV Turnoff Week, but better late than never:
A Reader’s Question
What is your family’s perspective on television? Do you let your kids watch it? Is it hard to set rules?
My Response
When it comes to television, our family has pretty much done it all and tried it all through the years. For the first year of our marriage, Dan and I had a large television with a cable connection and we watched TV every night. Then, when we moved to a house farther from the city, we decided we could not afford to pay for cable. Without cable in our new location, we received no channels and so that decided it for us. We packed our television into the closet and made great use of the local library. I have such happy memories of our family during that time—we had just two small children and we always had plenty to keep us occupied. Although I know Dan suffered from a lack of sports exposure, I don’t recall missing television at all during that time.
Then one day, our landlord came by to do some work on the house and asked where our TV was. When we told him we didn’t use a television, he almost fell to the floor. He felt so terribly bad for us, I remember him saying. And he had no idea that we were living like that. He was such a very nice and sympathetic guy that, despite our protests that we were perfectly content without television, he rummaged through the basement until he found a gigantic antenna. He then spent the rest of the afternoon installing it on the roof and hooking it up to the television he insisted we pull out of the closet. By the time he left, we received several local channels. As I recall, Dan immediately turned on a football game and settled on the couch. In the following couple of years, he got his weekly dose of sports and I got addicted to ER. Not so bad.
Then, when at last we moved here to our own house, we felt confident enough to pack up the television set and return it to a closet. We had a few more kids and they were getting older, though. On few different occasions (in the midst of stomach viruses and long weeks of blizzards) I did think, “Gee, a Winnie the Pooh video would sure come in handy.” Eventually, I stopped just thinking that and started saying it out loud. To my husband. And he listened. We got a VCR and started a library of our own family friendly videos. We had gotten it for the kids, but as it turned out Dan and I really started to enjoy renting movies together and having “grown up” down time the evening several times a week. That was not so bad, either.
Eventually, however, my poor deprived husband complained. He truly was sports deprived, he told me. He wanted to watch football games with his sons, just as he used to watch with his father. Keeping up with professional sports was an innocent pleasure he had long been denied. I took pity on him and okayed getting a satellite connection.
That was five years ago and we still have the satellite. We get local channels and some specialized channels and tons of channels we would never watch. We allow the kids restricted, supervised access to PBS, some cartoon channels, and some DVDs. We don’t have a set time limit in hours per week or anything like that because I don’t feel like we need to. The kids don’t watch every day. In fact, during the warmer weather when they can be outdoors, weeks can go by without anyone even asking for television.
Dan watches sporting events. And sports news. And sports talk shows. And sports game shows (Stump the Schwab anyone?). Are you picking up on the theme here? I am not so into sports but we do watch some shows together, like 24, Lost, and MythBusters.
The bottom line is, I see TV not as something intrinsically evil, but as a tool. One that can be used for good, but also one that can rather easily be abused. I surely don’t rely on TV or movies for educational purposes, but they can be a great source of family entertainment. And entertainment has its place.
I think, like so many things, there is no right or wrong answer when it comes to television and its use by families. I know of no-TV families, DVD-only families, all-kinds-of-TV families, and everything in between. They all have their reasons for using (or not using) television as they do and they all have made careful decisions based on what they deem best for their families.
Do I ever feel like we are watching too much? Yes. But that’s what the off button is for. Do I ever feel offended by something we inadvertently hear or witness on the television? Absolutely. But since we turn off or at least mute most commercials, it doesn’t happen very often. Do I sometimes worry that perhaps we are not handling TV exactly the way we should? Sure. But we parents are always second-guessing important decisions we make for our families, and then re-adjusting them as necessary. That’s our job. With God’s help and guidance, may we all do it well.
(By the way, for family friendly television and movie reviews and recommendations, check out Common Sense Media.)